Rooted on the Edge
of the Heartland
By ANN POWERS
The New York Times - August 10, 2000
Copyright 2000-2004 The New York Times Company
Rock
n roll demands some degree of self-exile. The musics
idiosyncratic champions do not fit easily into families, whether biological
or ideological. Yet many still want to claim a legacy to root their
visions, and especially as they grow older, many seek images in red,
white and blue.
Theres a whole subculture, Americana, devoted to the outcasts
reclamation of country and blues music. Steve Earle, the Ralph Nader
of country music, is its patriarch. Artists like the Jayhawks and Whiskeytowns
Ryan Adams, both of whom have new releases, have found artistic success
by stressing craft and tradition over trendiness. Sometimes the strum
and twang seem studied, but Americana artists offer a respite from the
mainstreams high-concept hard sell.
Even this homesteaders camp, however, has its outsiders. Four
of the best Americana-flavored albums of the summer are by artists who
arent the darlings of the post-punk bootstrap set. Theyve
all long mined the tension between rock iconoclasm and the urge to connect
to a legacy. These voices from the edge of the heartland enhance the
traditions they honor in music that invites listeners to contemplate
their own relationship to rootlessness.
Lonesome Cowboy
Chip and Tony Kinman have taken a twisted path to end up in a niche
that always suited them. These brothers first gained notice in the California
punk band the Dils, then practically founded the Americana style in
the raucous Rank and File. A detour into proto-electronica, as Blackbird,
didnt logically lead to Cowboy Nation, but the duo must have missed
those 10-gallon hats, because theyre wearing them now.
Cowboy Nation is a trio (Jamie Spidle plays drums) enacting a costume
drama
of western music. The bands originals detail barroom gunfights
and storm-chasing on the prairie, and the covers are chestnuts: ack
in the Saddle, Shenandoah. Yet for all its careful
re-enactment, Cowboy Nation is direct and unpretentious. Chip Kinmans
rumble of a voice embodies lonesomeness, and the trios taciturn
energy lends color to the legends it relates.
Making Blues New
Chris Whitley is an expert at finding something new in the exiles
stance. A Texas bluesman who incorporates East Village noise-rock into
his own songs, Mr. Whitley gives new faces to the demons of blues cliché.
On this amazing exercise in quiet intensity, he collaborates with the
jazz-fusion rhythm section Billy Martin and Chris Wood and the producer
Craig Street in taking a knife to a collection of classic rock and blues
songs.
Bookended by Spanish Harlem Incident and 4th Time
Around by Bob Dylan rocks original roots-ripper
Perfect Day also features songs by Lou Reed and the Doors,
Robert Johnson, Muddy Waters and Willie Dixon. Mr. Whitleys eerie,
tender voice dominates, often obscuring his fleet guitar and the rhythm
sections delicate rumble. What emerges is a portrait of introspection
that recalls other famous loners from Nick Drake to Chet Baker.
A Country Woman
As a member of the Picketts, Christy McWilson specialized in rootsy
fun. But the band never got far beyond the Seattle bar scene, and Ms.
McWilson endured several dark years of the soul. This album is a burst
out of inertia, an excellent account of the realistic life.
With help from her many friends, including the Blasters Dave Alvin,
who produced, Peter Buck and Mike Mills of R.E.M., Syd Straw and Rhett
Miller, Ms. McWilson offers finely wrought versions of her worldly-wise
songs. Her alto, in classic country fashion, mixes equal parts yearning
and resignation, and her accounts of motherhood and middle age rank
her as a star in the rapidly developing subgenre of grown-up gal music.
Fans of Amy Rigby and Patti Larkin shouldnt miss this album, where
theyll find more evidence of artistically fruitful adulthood.
All-Americana Classics
If one path of Americana leads back to the Kinman brothers, another
lands at the open kitchen door of Jason Ringenberg, the prototypical
country punk, who still sometimes leads his band of happy renegades,
the Scorchers. This album is a barn raiser more than a barn burner.
Its lovely songs, centered around Mr. Ringenbergs whippoorwill
croon, esteem family, history, and, yes, Christianity with characteristic
aplomb.
Nothing out of the ordinary jumps out of songs like the gospel stomper
Under Your Command, the Depression-era ballad The
Price of Progress, or Mr. Ringenbergs ode to his daughter,
For Addie Rose. But the music and Mr. Ringenbergs
voice are so good-naturedly alive that the themes, in classic Americana
fashion, are renewed.
©
2000-2004
The New York Times Company
All Rights Reserved